On the nature of theories/MAGIC DISHWASHER

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 47170

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Grey Wolf" <greywolf1 at j...> wrote:
> 
> > Alla,
> > who would like very much for MD to be proven wrong.
> 
> This is the worst form of bad manners in my own country, and a very 
> easy way of getting shouted at. I'm going to give the benfit of the 
> doubt once again, but saying that you hope for some other person's 
> theory to be proven wrong is not nice, unless you are pretty sure 
that 
> person would like it to be disproved too (as in a pessimistic 
theory).

OK, I am puzzled. I apologize if I hurt your feelings, because 
getting personal was definitely not my intention. 
Nevertheless I did intended to state my objection against MD version 
of events. I think I am allowed to do it. Maybe it was poorly phrased
(English is not my first language either, so please take it into 
consideration)and for that I am sorry. But I am honestly curious why 
hoping that theory would be proven wrong means bad manners.

When quoting me,you skipped the first part of the phrase (Respects MD 
as very creative theory), so I think I was respectful to you and 
other MD supporters. How can I not be if MD pulled me out of the 
lurker mode to try and state my objections. 

If you still would like to shout at me, please feel free to e-mail me 
off-list.
Alla