[HPforGrownups] Re: Gandalf and the Dishwasher

[Christopher Nuttall]

No: HPFGUIDX 47221

First, I dispute the 'gandalf as god' argument, I believe that while he has a history, he is 'just' a powerful magian and is bound by no laws, save by whatever laws the white council has, and that he is free to interfere as an individual as he sees fit.  

He provides advice, accompanies both the treasure seekers in 'the hobbit' and the fellowship in 'FOTR', advises the council, acts as peacemaker, defends people, etc.  There are many incidences of Gandalf being willing and able to act.  

Unlike Gandalf, who clearly is unable to defeat Sauron single handily, Dumbledore is Voldemort's equal (or so canon implies) and that is proved by Hogwarts never being seriously threatened by Voldemort.  I don't think that either of them seriously planned to leave their 'hobbits' to their own devices until the main threat was gone, at which point it is time for them to acknowledge that they are adults now.  Dumbledore will leave Hogwarts after Voldemort is destroyed. 

Gandalf shows himself willing to risk his own life to destroy the ring, and is only prevented from travelling to mount doom by circumstances (Thought: might Snape or Moody have a difference of opinion with Dumbledore that will lead to Harry being on his own at a crucial moment?).  I see no reason to doubt that Gandalf would have been there if he had been able to, and  he leads a divisionary action to help out as best as he can.  

Chris


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]