Some Questions = Theories Wanted

evenflow200214 daniel.brent at cwctv.net
Sat Nov 30 13:24:47 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 47462

1) How would Ron have explained to the rest of the Weasley's about 
the disappearence of Scabbers and aquiring Pig? We can see that they 
do not know that Sirius is innocent in GoF and Ron supposedly has no 
money... How would he explain Pig?

2)The Weasley's have a clock that tells each of them where each 
member of the family is, home, work etc... Why then, during Harry and 
Ron's adventures with the spiders, would the clock for Ron not appear 
on "mortal peril"? Or when Ginny was in the Chamber or talking to Tom 
wouldn't the Weasley's be straight over to Hogwarts, banging down 
Dumbledore's door? Or when Ron was trapped with Sirius? The clock 
doesn't know that he's innocent... And he's chained to a werewolf. 
Why doesn't the clock tell the Weasely's that they are in "mortal 
danger"?

3) Where is the proof that Crouch attacked the Longbottoms? Sorry to 
reiterate it but it has not been proven that he is guilty...

4) How was Sirius allowed a flying motorbike and why did Dumbledore 
not react at Privet Drive? As far as he knows, Sirius is responsible 
yet he lets what Hagrid says about Sirius giving him the motorbike go 
over his head and doesn't even stop Hagrid when he says he wants to 
take the bike back to Sirius? Is this Dumbledore being lacklustre or 
something else?

5) How did Sirius know where to find Peter after the Potter's deaths? 
He seems to track him down a little too easily... Did Peter plan that 
Sirius find him in that particular street? And was it part of his and 
Voldemort's original plan, to pretend to blow himself up, thus 
framing Sirius for three murders?

6) How do the Paintings exist? Were they people who chose to become 
paintings? Are the in the control of the artist that drew them?

7) Will Harry and Cho get together, in your opinions?

8) Why did Snape leave Voldemort and join him in the first place, in 
your opinions?

9)Why did Tom become Voldemort? Was there a trigger do you think?

10) Is Fudge merely corrupt, a good man at heart, or evil? And to 
what degree?

I know I've made some points I spoke about earlier but just trying to 
get some more discussion on it going...






More information about the HPforGrownups archive