How did Fudge know?
hogwarts_harry78
hogwarts_harry78 at yahoo.com
Sat Nov 30 16:36:10 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 47469
There's something that has been bugging me ever since I first read
Prisoner of Azkaban, and I haven't seen it discussed before (I
apologize if it has been, and I'd appreciate if someone could point
me to the relevant thread). It's in the last chapter of PoA, at the
end of the conversation between Fudge and Dumbledore in the hospital
wing (British paperback edition, page 453):
"'And the Dementors?' said Dumbledore. 'They'll be removed from the
school, I trust?'
'Oh, yes, they'll have to go,' said Fudge, running his fingers
distractedly through his hair. 'Never dreamed they'd attempt to
administer the Kiss on an innocent boy ... completely out of
control ..."
Now, my question is: how does Fudge know that a Dementor tried to
kiss Harry? Snape couldn't have told him that, because he says he has
no idea what made the Dementors retreat, and he adds, "By the time I
had come round they were heading back to their positions at the
entrances ..." (page 417). Hermione and Sirius were unconscious by
the time the Dementor tried to administer the Kiss. The only person
who knows about the whole thing is Harry, and we know he hasn't told
Fudge anything. So, how did Fudge find out? The only theory I can
come up with is that he is indeed evil and that he was the one who
ordered the Dementors to kiss Harry in the first place. Any other
ideas? Or am I missing something obvious?
This is my first post, by the way, so I hope I did everything
right. :)
Andi
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive