The echo's from V's wand in GoF

freya122000 rlundgren at gov.mb.ca
Thu Oct 3 15:31:06 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 44881

I know that a passage in GoF was re-edited in later additions of the 
book.  One thing was not changed, the order in which Lily and James 
come out of the wand.  By the way I have nothing to back this up, 
anyway:  Perhaps the order is not wrong at all.  Perhaps James did 
die after Lily.  V stated that James put up quite a fight in the 
house.  What if V "believing" James dead heads to finish off Lily and 
Harry.  He AK's Lily and turns on Harry, and as his curse is 
rebounding he is hit from behind by a mortally wounded James.  The 
rebounding curse killing James and V blasted to nothing.  Just a 
thought.  Freya






More information about the HPforGrownups archive