Harry's innate abilities
jodel at aol.com
jodel at aol.com
Tue Oct 8 18:09:02 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 45111
Interesting thread, but we've gotten off into a fruitless comparison between
sports and music. No one seems to be carrying the observation back a step to
a point where it makes somewhat better sense.
Quidditch skills, per se, are probably not inheritible. But those Quidditch
skills are the finished product. You don't start with the finished product,
you start with the ingredients, and those very well might be inherited
tendencies. For example;
A good sense of balance may be inherited. Good reflexes may be. The sort of
agility necessary to be able to change direction quickly without falling over
or loosing control may be. A good sense of timing, good hand and eye
coordination probably are. (Not necessarily vision. Both Harry and his father
seem to have had to wear glasses -- or are James's glasses fanon?)
Quidditch skills are composed of may other elements and rather a lot of them
are things which an individual CAN inherit at least a nacent tendency toward,
which can be trained in whatever direction the possesser of them might
choose. There is a very reasonable likelihood of Harry's having inherited at
least some of these basic strengths from one or both of his parents.
-JOdel
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive