Harry's innate abilities
animagi_raven
niemuthervin at worldnet.att.net
Wed Oct 9 01:59:52 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 45128
I was going to avoid this thread but I feel that I have something to
add. It might end up that I just add a long post, but I want to see
if I can get through this without being AKed by a genetics major or
Crucio-ed by a moderator for being OT. Hang in there, I have to
start with inherited genetics but I do get to a very interesting
thought that is on-topic (I promise)!
I'll start with a simple, measurable statistic such as height. For
two people of exceptional height, the male children's height will not
be a simple normal (bell-shaped) curve about their father's height,
but will be a skewed curve trending back towards the genetic
average. There is an influence from the mother's height as well.
Keep that last thought, we'll come back to that.
Now for a seeker, there are possibly hundreds of factors that affect
raw ability (balance, sight, hand-eye coordination, recklessness,
etc.), some more than others. I am talking strictly raw ability here
since Harry's ability is noticed the first time that he is on a broom
and he has never seen Quidditch played before that first broom lesson
in PS. Since he is the `best seeker in over 100 years' (rats, can't
find the quote just now) and his father is described a `an excellent
Quidditch player' (McGonagall, p.152 SS) he is probably beyond his
father's talents at flying.
If his ability is genetically based and discounting that his
abilities were not enhanced by some kind of magic (like that Anakin
kid), Harry got the basis for his exceptional abilities from his
father and mother. His father's gave him a good start. His mother's
abilities have not been discussed to this point in the books. Unless
he got incredibly lucky (OK, possible in a book) his mother's
abilities were possibly equal to or better than his father's for some
of those abilities. There could also be synergistic affects between
the abilities he got from his parents. That part of genetics gets
beyond me.
I am also willing to accept that there was some early training of his
abilities in balance, dodging, and observation by staying away from
Dudley and his gang. So therefore, IMO Harry's abilities came from
both parents, some genetic luck, and some early training of some of
his abilities. Everybody gets to be a little right.
My guess is that his vision or awareness will be from his mother
because of those green eyes. It would be a nice literary touch.
Animagi-Raven who does not think of himself as `moderated' but
rather `under constant supervision for the benefit of society'.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive