The fight against tyranny: the central theme of HP
bugaloo37
crussell at arkansas.net
Mon Oct 14 15:51:10 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 45314
All the posts concerning possible themes of HP, really got me to
thinking-what is the central theme? The one from which all themes
seem to begin. I have a theory on this issue and I wish to post it-
to see what other members think. My theory is this: the central
theme of the HP series is the fight against tyranny. This could also
be termed learning to think for yourself. Let's consider the
following: what distinguished the witches/wizards who were killed by
Voldemort and those that were not? IMO, it was there unwillingness
to go along with his scheme. Those who capitulated on some level
were spared. Why were certain witches/wizards targeted? It can be
argued that there is something in particular regarding the Potters-
Jame and Harry-something that singled them out. But what about the
others? the non-Potters, as it were? We know Voldemort killed
others? IMO, they too represented some kind of threat to his
scheme. Was it merely because they resisted? Could be. Dumbledore
has spent a lot of time on the issue of choice with Harry- without
giving him a complete explanation for why Voldemort wanted him dead.
IMO, Dumbledore is trying to get Harry strong enough mentally and
spiritually to deal with this knowledge- it must be something pretty
powerful. Still, IMO, all this preparation is necessary to combat
tyranny- to give the best possible weapon to Harry he can possess-
not magical abilities, although I do believe they will be utilized-
but a strong and resiliant spirit-which he has already demonstrated.
IMO, when Harry thinks for himself, he has an incredible weapon- one
that Voldemort with all of his power, has a hard time overcoming.
bugaloo37
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive