Another Shrieking Shack?Re: Pettigrew: Snape Through the Looking Glass

lucky_kari lucky_kari at yahoo.ca
Fri Oct 25 20:43:34 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 45786

Elkins wrote a wonderful post about Pettigrew and Snape being mirrors
of each other.

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "ssk7882" <skelkins at a...> wrote:
> Both men are traitors.  Both men acted as moles during the war.  
> 
> More specifically, both betrayed their old circle of school friends 
> by passing on information to the enemy, information which eventually 
> led to some of their friends' violent deaths.  
> 
> In both cases, this old circle of school friends included people who 
> were killed in the last year of the war (the Potters, Rosier, 
> Wilkes), those who were sent to Azkaban but who have either already 
> escaped or who seem likely to be liberated in the near future (Black, 
> the Lestranges), and those who may have escaped death or 
> imprisonment, but who nonetheless seem to have suffered profound 
> psychological damage as they have not achieved much of anything with 
> their lives in the years since the war (Lupin, Avery).  
> 
> Both circles also included a married couple (Lestranges, Potters), 
> including a woman who was both the token female member of the group 
> and unusually talented and/or formidable. 

So, given these parallels, are we going to see another Shrieking
Shack? In PoA Pettigrew had to face his friends whom he had betrayed.
Will Snape have to face Avery and the Lestranges? 

I think it's clear that there will have to come a time when Voldemort
finally figures out what's up with Severus Snape and if JKR really
wants to get an emotional punch out of it what better than to have
Snape's old friends present?

Eileen





More information about the HPforGrownups archive