Snape's office sealed? (short)

ats_fhc3 the.gremlin at verizon.net
Tue Sep 3 00:39:27 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 43516

> bboy_mn comments:
> 
> When Hermione stole supplies, they were from the supply stores in 
the
> classroom. Other references to Snapes office haven't given me the
> impression that it is in or near the potions classroom. Well, it's
> certainly in the dungeon, but I get no indication that it is 
attached
> to the potions classroom. 
> 
> So I don't think Hermione stole supplies from Snape's private 
office,
> but from his private supplies cuboard/room in the classroom. 
> 
> I don't have it here in front of me, but I think we might have two
> separate events. One is Moody/Couch in Snape's Office as seen on 
the
> Map, and Snape's later statement that ingredients were missing from
> his private stock. Those two are not necessarily the same event.
> 
> Just some thoughts.
> 
> bboy_mn

Actually, in CoS, when Snape is taking Harry and Ron to his office, 
Harry is talking (or thinking about) walking through the dungeons. 
I, too, however, don't have the books with me, seeing as how they 
are at home, and I am at school, and I "forgot" to pack them. 

And if Moody was going to steal potions ingredients from Snape's 
private stores, and Snape's private stores are in the classroom, why 
would Snape and/or Harry see Moody/Crouch in Snape's office? And I 
don't think Moody was *actually* searching Snape's office...

-Acire, who wonders where the teachers sleep.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive