(WAS Harry and the Pheonex)

[gabrielle jones]

No: HPFGUIDX 43578


ok I can't resist. 

bboy_mn writes:
>>The Chosen One-
This is also a valid option and comon in fairytales. It could be that
among all the drops of Gryffindor blood out there, the chosen one, the
crown prince is selected or predicted perhaps by the reading of the
stars, or the Gryffindor who purely and unselfishly displays the
characteristics of a true Gryffindor, or perhaps by searching and
finding the 'holy grail'; the completion of a quest, or perhaps by the
approval, bond, and friendship of a gold and red pheonix. 

Again, the point is here, that the Heir to Gryffindor could be a
'chosen one' selected not by purity of blood or direct descendance but
by being the purest, truest, and noblest Gryffindor at heart. Kind of
romanic, don't you think?

This 'Chosen One' theory doesn't discount choices, because Harry still
has to choose and live by the pure, true and noble character of
Gryffindor.

Just some thoughts.

bboy_mn<<

How about a "King Arthur, Sword in the stone thing?" 

Trelawney's prediction, could have been that, "he who able to pull Grffindor's sword from his hat, is the heir to his name." or something like that. Heck, if you wanted you could even continue her prediction to say that the Slytherin heir would attack the Grffindor heir, or i don't know. And maybe, ok i know i'm streching it a bit, but Dumbledore, too, could be the heir, because when fighting against Grindelwald, he used Grffindor's sword. Then Harry and he are both the heirs. Even Fawkes could play into it, like whoever controls the sword gets the bird. 

I don't know. I'm really just making a fun plot line, i know there must be a million reasons it can't work. But there must be more to the sword. Shoot me down gently.

Gabrielle







---------------------------------
Do You Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Finance - Get real-time stock quotes

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]