[HPforGrownups] New Prediction for Book 5

Shannon srae1971 at iglou.com
Sat Sep 7 13:00:30 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 43748

At 12:19 PM 9/7/2002 -0000, vixinalizardqueen at hotmail.com wrote:

>My new prediction for book 5 (or actually, any of the future books 
>really) is that Voldemort is going to give Harry a major choice 
>between something that is easy, and something that is right. When 

<snip>

>I think this would be a really good way to illustrate the difficult 
>choice between what is easy and what is right (a theme which JKR said 
>in a few interviews will feature in a major role in the coming books). 
>Actually, I think that kind of idea was first used in "the Magician's 
>Nephew" by C. S Lewis, but oh well, I think it would be such an 
>interesting/thought provoking/heart wrenching thing to see Harry have 
>to make such a decision.

It's probably a safe bet.  Such a choice is actually at the heart of nearly
every fantasy story worth reading.  Sometimes the story is in keeping the
path that decision leads to, and sometimes it's the buildup to it. I think
Harry Potter is the build up to it.  At some point, Harry is going to have
a moment of truth from which there is no going back. When that time comes
remains to be seen, but I do believe it is coming.  

Shannon






More information about the HPforGrownups archive