Hagrid Flew?
doffy99
doffy99 at yahoo.com
Mon Sep 9 16:22:48 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 43812
I wrote:
> > The question becomes I guess, How did Hagrid get to the Island
where
> > Uncle Vernon had Harry stashed to avoid those letters? We know he
> > flew, but HOW did he fly?
Andrea wrote:
> I have not one shred of canon to back this up, other than he had it
with
> him at the time, but I always pictured Hagrid flying in like Mary
Poppins
> on his pink umbrella. :)
Me:
This does create an interesting mental image LOL and I'm sure it's
exactly what Harry was thinking when Hagrid told him he flew.
Is Hagrid enough of a wizard to cast such a spell though?? This seems
like awful powerful magic. At least as big a deal as Tranfiguration
and one, I would think, a wizard would use sparingly and possibly
only with permission from MOM. Good chance of being seen and all.
Granted, Harry and family were in a remote area and it was dark and
stormy. We have NO canon at all to say that A wizard could even cast
such a spell, that such a spell even exists, unless Hagrid knows the
spell to make a Brookstick fly. This doesn't seem like a spell you
would learn in your forth or fifth year at Hogwarts.
Did Dumbledore or someone else Train Hagrid to do this? I admit, I've
predicted in an earlier post that Hagrid would become a full fledged
wizard by the end of series, but this seems a little advanced.
Any thoughts on the idea that Dumbledore has been slowly, over many,
many years, training Hagrid in wizardy? Dumbledore trusts Hagrid
implicitly and Dumbledore does have a certain disregard for rules,
much like our hero, is it possible that Hagrid is closer to being a
wizard than JKR has let on?
-Jeff
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive