Hagrid Flew?

frankielee242 speedygonzo242 at hotmail.com
Mon Sep 9 20:59:13 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 43824

Jeff (doffy99)wrote:
>  
> > How did Hagrid fly over to the island to get Harry? Hagrid isn't a 
> > fully trained wizard. He couldn't use a spell to fly? He obviously 
> > couldn't apparate. So how did he get there? If he KEPT the bike, 
> > then he could have flown that, but where did it go? 
>  

What if Hagrid took a portkey? The sensation of using a portkey as
described from Harry's PoV in the beginning of GoF seemed a bit like
flying and rather unpleasant. Especially if you're someone who gets
motion-sickness like Hagrid did in the Gringott's carts... Also in
GoF, Amos Diggory announced he'd be glad when Cedric passed his
Apparation tests and they didn't have to use them anymore. 

Hagrid might have brushed off the use of a portkey as "flying" since
it became obvious Harry had no idea he was a wizard and knew nothing
about the WW. Also, Hagrid might not have known how to explain how a
portkey worked. Taking the boat, rather than the portkey buried in one
of his many pockets, back to the mainland was a lot easier for both
Hagrid and Harry to deal with.


Frankie, the devil's advocate on weekends and holidays and all
throughout May...





More information about the HPforGrownups archive