Harry Can Hold Both A Wand And Another Object (WAS: Harry's wands)

ffimiles ffionmiles at hotmail.com
Thu Sep 12 15:31:12 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 43937

As regards the wand and cup holding - remember, you only need to 
touch a portkey with a finger - you stick to it, as they all were 
when touching to old wellington boot to get to the Quidditch World 
Cup - so Harry needn't've fully grasped the cup'shandle...
Another, thoroughly petty thing - he lands on the Quidditch pitch 
after the cup (portkey) brings him back to Hogwarts - face down, 
Cderic's wrist in one hand, cup in the other - and Dumbledore manages 
to turn him over -e ven though he doesn't elt go of Cedric - wouldn't 
his arms get totallyt wisted?  
As ever though, I feel disrespectful picking JKR up on such things - 
she can't think everything through i suppose - though this 5th book 
is taking so long, I expect everything to be chronologically and 
physically possible!!!

Ffi





More information about the HPforGrownups archive