Apparating on Hogwarts grounds
Julie Stahlhut
julie.k.stahlhut at alum.mit.edu
Fri Sep 13 02:53:41 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 43973
I don't really see anything that says it's impossible to learn to
apparate on Hogwarts grounds, or that Hogwarts couldn't
possibly offer any instruction in that art. I've always interpreted
the text to mean that only *unauthorized* apparation was
forbidden (presumably prevented by charms). As an analogy, a
high school may offer a driver's education class but not permit
students to drive or park a car on the grounds just because
they're licensed; the school might have regulations that, for
example, only seniors could do so, even if some sophomores
and juniors are old enough to get a license.
Also, I assumed that the test that permitted one to apparate at
will was not administered at Hogwarts. Again, in the U.S. you
normally take your driver's test at a state department of motor
vehicles office; do similar offices of a local or national agency
administer this test in Britain? If so, that kind of analogy in the
wiz-world would make sense too.
Julie
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive