Hufflepuffs (WAS:Neville and the sorting hat)
Grey Wolf
greywolf1 at jazzfree.com
Fri Sep 13 07:06:31 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 43976
Gail Bohacek wrote:
> There seems to be a bias against the illustrious Hufflepuff House
> (*cough*fyrewood*cough*) and I'm wondering why is that?
>
> Could somebody please tell me where Hufflepuff got this bad rap?
> And, in general, why are the qualities which Hufflepuffs are said to
> possess not valued like the others?
>
>
> -Gail B. who is going off to have a good sulk.
Hufflepuff gets a bad rap in the books, Gail, right at the
begining.This is what canon says about them:
Draco says: "imagine being in Hufflepuff, I think I'd leave, wouldn't
you?"
but of course this is Draco we're speakng about, who doesn't understand
loyalty. At that point, however, we *don't* know him (although we've
concluded he's a stupid classist a few lines before), but he gives no
reason about wy Hufflepuff is so bad.Harry doesn't, either, so later he
asks Hagrid about the houses. Hagrid's answer (about Hufflepuff) is:
"Everyone says Hufflepuff are a lot o' duffers, but --"
"Better Hufflepuff than Slytherin, There's not a single witch or wizard
who went bad wwho wasn't in Slytherin. You-Know-Who was one."
Notice that, although Slytherin is definetely placed as the baddies'
house, Hagrid (who by now is placed in the "good guys") actually
doesn't refute the "they're a lot o' duffers", and thus both good and
bad guys agree on this... sort of. And sice the attention is neatly
diverted from Hufflepuff into Slytherin, you may remain wth the
impression that they *are* a lot o' duffers. I certainly did, the first
time around, although when I got to the sorting hat, my perceptions
changed somewhat.
Hope that helps,
Grey Wolf
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive