Snape: What is he up to?

ats_fhc3 the.gremlin at verizon.net
Sat Sep 14 01:34:10 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 44005

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "bugaloo37" <crussell at a...> wrote:
> In a previous post, I mentioned the fact that I found the 
character 
> of Snape intriging.  IMO, Harry is as confused about Snape as I 
am.  
> After learning about the werewolf incident and James' rescue of 
> Snape,  I still do not feel satisfied that this is the root of 
> Snape's ambiguous relationship with Harry.  Now please let me 
> apologize before I say this:  I do not see the unrequited love 
> scenario as being a plausible explanation either ( I know a lot of 
> people out there do-but please don't hate me!).  I just got to 
> thinking (too much time on my hands- I guess)- are there anymore 
> theories out there concerning Snape's ambiguous relationship with 
> Harry other than the childhood grudge or unrequited love 
theories?  I 
> am really interested in getting more information on this 
particular 
> subject. 
> 
> bugaloo37-who is really trying to figure Snape out.

In Message 43274 I posed my "wild theory" (because I can't stand the 
Snape+Lily thing) than Snape may have had a wife/lover and kid 
stashed somewhere, at the same time Lily and James were married, and 
had Harry. 

My idea was that Mrs. Snape and Severus Jr. died as a result of 
Snape's being a DE, and then being a spy. Then I went furthr and 
propesed the theory that wife/lover and kid died around the same 
time as the Potters, and that Snape hates Harry because Harry lived, 
and Snape's wife/lover and young'un didn't.

I also thought of the theory that the reason Snape turned was simply 
because he decided that with wife and the pattering of little feet 
to worry about, he had too much to risk.

-Acire, who is wondering if anyone else has a hard time 
associating "wizard" with "Snape".









More information about the HPforGrownups archive