Dumbledores house and a little of Snape

theresnothingtoit mi_shell16 at hotmail.com
Wed Sep 18 20:15:57 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 44169

Is there any actually evidence, canon or interview, that sates that 
Dumbledore was in Gryffindor?  I know it seems the obvious choice but 
I am sure it is never stated clearly in the books.  Hagrid does 
mention that "they say" Dumbledore was in Gryffindor but I am a 
little apprehensive as taking this a hard truth.

Anyway the only other house that I could see Dumbledore being in is 
Hufflepuff.  The only reason being is that he is very forgiving and 
gives people second chances.  The Hufflepuff ghost (the fat friar, I 
believe) is constantly trying to give Peeves a second chance but the 
Bloody Baron (Slytherin ghost) will have none of it.

This led me to think of Snape.  I believe that he is so mean 
partially because he can't forgive himself for what he has done as a 
DE and, if he were in Dumbledores position, would not believe his 
redemption for a second.  That is why he respects Dumbledor so much 
but also gets so annoyed at him as well.  I can see Snape being 
completely mystified by unconditional trust.

Theresnothingtoit
(who is carefully packing her books so she doesn't forget to take 
them to university)






More information about the HPforGrownups archive