Muggles/Muggle-born: what's the difference?
bugaloo37
crussell at arkansas.net
Mon Sep 23 15:13:33 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 44366
First of all, I want to thank everyone who responded to my Sirius
Black post-even the ones who do not like him. It was good to find
out that a lot of people agree with me-at least, about Sirius. I
want to introduce a new topic if I can. There seems to be some
confusion concerning the difference between a muggle and a muggle-
born. Even Tom Riddle aka Voldemort seems to interchange the two
phrases at will. Someone mentioned in an earlier post, that to
someone like Voldemort, the difference between muggles and muggle-
borns is virtually non-existant. In other words, he detests them
both equally- as do people like the Malfoys. IMO, the difference
between them is small- but it is an important difference. Have you
ever noticed that when someone like the Weasleys' or Dumbledore
refers to a witch or wizard with no wizard heritage, they always use
the term "muggle-born"-in this case, it is not an insult, but merely
a way of distinguishing. When someone like Draco, uses the term( he
usually uses the word, "mudblood"-which is ten times worse)-it is
meant to be an insult. In other words, at least in this situation,
context is important. The Weasleys understand there is a difference
between being a pure-blood and a muggle-born- but the difference
simply holds no importance to them whatsoever. IMO, here are the
definitions, as far as I can make out: Muggles are non-magical
humans-no magical abilities-no magical heritage. Muggle-borns are
witches and wizards-they have magical abilities-but no magical
heritage. In CoS, Tom Riddle refers to Lily Potter as being "muggle-
born"- a witch (most definitely!) with no magical ancestry. In GoF,
Voldemort compares Lily to his own hated father- a muggle. However,
he does use the word "almost" when comparing the two- as you can see,
even Voldemort knows there is a difference between the two. In other
words, what it comes down to, IMO, is this: Voldemort treats Muggles
and Muggle-borns the same-even though one group is magical and the
other is not. Magical abilities carry no weight is his
classification system-only heritage. The Weasleys and those like
them- treat everyone regardless of heritage and/or magical abilities
with respect.
bugaloo37
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive