All Dark Wizards come from Slytherin
bugaloo37
crussell at arkansas.net
Wed Sep 25 15:40:17 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 44465
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Gilaine Shadow" <gilaine at g...> wrote:
><snip>
>In all the classifications that the sorting hat has declared it has
never said that purity of blood (Voldemort is half-blood) or
hatred/anger at muggles was necessary.<snip>
Now me:
I believe you are correct-the Sorting Hat has never mentioned the
need of pure-blood in order to be sorted into Slytherin;however, it
was mentioned that Salazar Slytherin did not wish muggle-borns to be
allowed into Hogwarts. Tom Riddle was a half-blood and I believe his
resentment of muggles was already present in his personality when he
entered Hogwarts due to his fathers (a muggle) treatment of his
mother (a witch). If, IMO, the Sorting Hat is "filled" as it were,
with the likes and dislikes of the four original co-founders of
Hogwarts and bases its decisions to some degree on these "opinions",
IMO, hatred of muggles and muggle-borns would be something for the
hat to look for when sorting students. I do not believe it has ever
been mentioned, but IMO, I would seriously doubt if you would find a
muggle-born in Slytherin house (remember, Tom Riddle is a half-blood,
not a muggle-born-there is a difference). For a backup on this idea,
remember in CoS when all the muggle-borns were being attacked not a
single member of Slytherin house was targeted ("Enemies of the heir
beware"). I am not saying that all members of Slytherin share this
blind hatred of muggles and muggle-borns but it does seem to be a
distinguishing characteristic of that particular house; nor do I
believe that all Slytherins turn bad. IMO,ambition can be a dangerous
thing-it must always remain considerate of others-or it can do great
harm.
bugaloo37
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive