SHIP: H/H, H/R or other?/Harry gaining Independence

Fyre Wood fyredriftwood at yahoo.com
Mon Sep 30 17:50:54 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 44705

Risti kindly posted:

> 
> Harry Potter is clearly the main protagonist, and the key focus of 
> this series.  Already, he is faced with the fact that he is an 
orphan 
> due to tragic circumstances, he's grown up in a non supportive 
> family, and most of the world counts on him to save them from 
certain 
> peril.  There's alot resting on the shoulders of this teenage 
> character.
> 
> Keep in mind that Harry is the narrator, which means that whatever 
is 
> on his heart is what we read.  In my opinion, if a love interest 
> starts to be the thing most on his heart, we are going to lose 
focus 
> of what's really important.
> 

Fyre Wood (ME) replies:

Any relationship between Harry and a girl would ruin the whole basis 
of the story. It's a good vs evil story, and a romance would ruin it. 
Harry just can't love anyone.




>>>>>>>>>>> I am of the opinion that Harry will have girl problems-
crushes, 
> awkward dates, maybe even a first kiss or two, but a serious, full 
> hearted love relationship?  


I reply:

I can't see Harry falling in love with a girl and having a 
relationship. (Perhaps it's the Draco/Harry shipper in me?) But 
realistically, anything/anyone he loves always gets hurt. He can't 
afford to not only try to protect himself, but also try to protect 
another loved one. He's lost a lot already--and losing another loved 
one would probably tear him to shreds.

He can't get romantically invovled. IMO, he's going to die at the end 
of the series, thus making any sort of attempt at a lasting romance 
impossible. 

Though, I'd like to see perhaps a frolic or two in the Astronomy 
Tower, or perhaps a sex talk with Ron and all the details....?



>>>>>Before you all go yelling at me, remember that 
> the series is all about Harry.  He's the narrator, the one in the 
> titles, and the one in whom all the plot points ultimately revolve 
> around.  So far, in all the books, despite any help he may get, 
> ultimately, it is Harry who has the final say.
> 

I reply:

Unfortunately we only get to see a one-sided, bias view of 
everything. I would have rather seen more of the fights between 
Ron/Hermione after the Yule Ball, or maybe gotten into the mind of 
Cho Chang and why she rejects Harry. maybe she knows that getting 
involved with the Boy Wonder will only lead to trouble.

One thing is for sure: Don't mess with Harry, for when you do, you'll 
only die.
(ie: Cedric took his girl to the dance, and he died... Lockhart tried 
to kill Harry and he went insane.... Riddle tried to kill Harry and 
he was killed... see my point?)

--Fyre Wood, who proudly chants the "Harry is GOD!" theory over and 
over again.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive