is petunia dursley a squib?
marephraim
htfulcher at comcast.net
Mon Sep 30 11:52:23 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 44706
>Re Msg: 44598 Re: is petunia dursley a squib?
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., rvotaw at i... (Richelle?) wrote:
>
> If indeed Petunia is a squib instead of Lily being a muggle born,
there must be some really really good reason for Lily to basically
enter Hogwarts under a false pretense of being a muggle born. If,
perhaps, she had a "bad name" that Dumbledore or whoever didn't want
her associated with or stereotyped by, claiming to be muggle born
would explain why no one knew her "new name."
>
> Richelle
I've heard this kind of discussion from several boards although
I've never taken much thought of it.
The interesting thing about this exchange is the possible connection
to the thread #44583 "Harry's Relatives: his Uncle Voldemort and
his sister Hermione"(in this group) about He Who Must Not Be Named's
possible family relationship to Harry. In that discussion it is
posited that the Potters were hiding precisely because You Know Who
was seeking to kill them because they were his relatives.
It's a short exchange, however I need to review the whole history of
Riddle as from GoF.
Of course this could just all be a flint.
MarEprhaim
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive