[HPforGrownups] Charlie's Wand.

FlamingStar Chows flamingstarchows at att.net
Sat Apr 5 15:53:18 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 54823

----- Original Message -----
Alex Fox wrote:
Absolutly BRILLIANT post, Bboy! I especially like the "different tree,
different effect" idea.  Now enlighten me on why, if Ollivander knew that
V.'s wand gave Harry the scar, and if he "knows every wand he has ever
sold", why he didn't know that Tom Riddle was V.! It HAD to be his same wand
that he had, because of the "Priori Incantatum"! Am I just tripping?Or did
Tom get a NEW wand after Hogwarts? HELP! This has been bugging me for weeks,
and I can't get an answer!

---Me---
I'd say from his statement that Ollivander *did* know that Tom Riddle was
Voldemort.  Dumbledore stated that *not many* people knew that Voldemort was
once the clever, handsome, head boy there, not that *no one* knew.  It
wouldn't surprise me in the least if Ollivander was one of the ones who did
know, if for no other reason than *because* of the wand.

~Cathy~





More information about the HPforGrownups archive