Pettigrew in Gryffindor? (was: Tom-Harry-Choices / Wand-Transformation / Questions / Wzdg)

[beanneboy]

No: HPFGUIDX 54889

Troels wrote
 
> I fully believe that James Potter actually was in
> Gryffindor, and the above is part of what has
> convinced me, but it does not constitute actual
> proof.
> 
> I am less certain about James' friends. Peter seems
> a very unlikely Gryffindor, while Sirius and Remes
> could both be either of the non-Slytherin houses.
> This has been the source of much debate, but as far
> as I am aware no real concensus has ever emerged
> anywhere ;-)

now me: I personally feel that its very likely that they were all in 
the same house, whether that be Gryffindor or not. The reason I say 
that is because generally throught out the series thus far 
friendships are few and far between between the different houses, I 
am not saying there are not friends (becuase of the lessons with 
other houses). In POA they talked of James and Sirius as inseparable, 
(dont have quotes, sorry) so that would be very difficult if they 
were in different houses. I have nothing to say about the other two 
other than I think it unlikely they all became the great friends they 
did without being housed together.

If anyone has anything I have missed let me know I have not got round 
to re-reading POA recently.

lee (who is very much looking forward to seeing the new Gryffindor 
quidditch team)