Voldemorts wand/Phoenix

[finwitch]

No: HPFGUIDX 54936

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Michele Hahn:

> Moepi from Luxembourg 
> Persisting questions :
> 
> 1.Does Priori Incantatum only show spells which worked properly ?
> 2.Is there only one possible echo for each spell ? (screams for 
Crucio, Echo of Victim for Avada Kedavra, a replay for spells 
creating things( silver hand, dark mark, sleeping bags...))
> 
> 3.Did Voldemort use another wand to AK Harry ?
> 
> 4.Is there any stuff in Theorybay yet presuming that there was 
somebody or something else then Harry's mother's sacrifice making the 
curse backfire ? 

Finwitch: 
1. Well, it might indeed be so. Only spells that worked... Harry is 
somewhat immune to Imperius, as he can shook it off. But what 
Imperius would look/sound/smell like.. no idea.

2. Well, I think that the echo must be related to the curse and be 
one for each for Priori incantatum to be useful.

3. Why should/would he suddenly change his wand for the kid?

4. Well - I think it *might* be the phoenix feather in Voldemort's 
wand... Like well - I doubt that the phoenix-cage to form and Phoenix-
song is heard with other brother-wands, only those from same phoenix. 
Fawkes is faithful to his feathers(which might explain how Dumbledore 
keeps an eye on Harry - Fawkes tells him!)...

How do you think Fawkes knew that Harry was "showing true loyalty to 
Dumbledore" in CoS and to bring the hat? Fawkes is *always* connected 
to the feathers he has donated. Always. It might even be that phoenix 
must approve of donation or the wand won't work...
-
Only few wizards have been able to domesticate a phoenix.
Only few wizards have been chosen by a phoenix-feather wand.
Only few wizards can summon a patronus.
Only few wizards can overthrow Imperius Curse.
Only few wizards dare speak Lord Voldemort's name aloud.
-
We know that all these but domesticating a phoenix have to do with 
Harry, so the question is, will Harry be taking care of Fawkes 
because something happens to Dumbledore, also domesticate a phoenix?

Harry's wand has Fawkes' tail-feather, his loyalty to Dumbledore has 
summoned Fawkes (Fawkes knew of Prongs?), Harry's seen the bird's 
recent rebirth and now Harry has also defeated battle of wills with 
the brother-wand, hearing Fawkes sing (did Harry hear Dumbledore 
during the wand-battle, or am I imagining?)...

Supposedly, once Dumbledore is gone, Fawkes will be Harry's pet?
I wonder, when Dumbledore talked with Sirius - did he have Fawkes 
with him? He'd know for sure that Sirius is innocent if Sirius was 
encouraged by Fawkes' singing.

-- Finwitch