one more death question
peabwain
peabwain at yahoo.com
Wed Apr 9 02:20:40 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 54989
I am fairly new to this list, and I am only on my second reading of
GoF. I don't know if this has been discussed to death. If it has
you could just give me the message number. But I was wondering a few
things:
Who is Voldemort talking about when he says, "one more death and
our
path to Harry Potter is clear"? (US paperback GoF pg 10) Why
can't
Voldemort commit the murder himself? He was able to kill Bertha
Jorkins and Frank Bryce.
I assumed it was Crouch Sr. & Voldemort could not do it because
Crouch is a more powerful wizard than he was at the time, but
didn't
Voldemort need Crouch so the ministry would not become suspicious?
Crouch only died because he escaped & Voldemort was afraid he would
tell Dumbledore everything. Or maybe he was talking about Crouch the
whole time he just had to do it a little sooner than was planned
because he escaped.
I know at the end of GoF Dumbledore says that Voldemort killed
Cedric when we know that Wormtail actually did it as Finwich pointed
out in the Graveyard Scene post on March 27.
<snip>It's not a lie; it just shows
something about commands: It's the one giving command who's *doing*
it, the one obeying is just a tool.
Is this what happened with Bertha too. Voldemort is taking credit
because he told Wormtail to do it? Can Voldemort only kill muggles
because they are too weak (magically) to fight back? (Eww. That's
kind of like killing kittens don't you think?) Or have I
completely
missed the Hogwarts Express and Voldemort is talking about the real
Mad-Eye Moody. But even then doesn't Moody need to remain alive
in
order for the Polyjuice Potion to work?
So there you go. Welcome to my head. You're welcome to stay, but
please follow the rules.
"peabwain"
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive