Professor Trelawney's "experience"

[GKJPO]

No: HPFGUIDX 55058

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "devonturcotte" 
<devonturcotte at y...> wrote:
> For me, I just always took Trelawney's statement as meaning she has 
> experience in "seeing."  She can see that Harry is obviously having 
> some kind of vision that ends in him clutching his scar.  I don't 
> think it goes any deeper than that.  I don't know that anyone knows 
> anything about a curse scar like Harry's.  No one's ever had one 
> before.
> 
This is how I interpreted it too the other gagillion - 1 times I read 
it, but if you read the passage literally, I don't think she's saying 
that.  Though, regardless of the interpretation, I still feel that 
the scene has some major foreshadowing.  Harry will at some point 
figure out that his scar has more powers and it may very well be 
Trelawney that helps him (probably unwittingly).  

>Has anyone else noticed 
> that Harry's predictions are always right?  
<snip>
> I wonder if this points to Harry's possible future as and Auror or 
> even a true Seer?
> 
> devonturcotte

Yes, I believe it's been discussed on and off. It is also pointed out 
that Ron's predictions also come true.  Though I can't remember all 
the details or the threads.  

Kristen