Another puzzle about Voldemort's wand
Meg Demeranville
mdemeran at hotmail.com
Thu Apr 10 05:08:47 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 55070
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "finwitch" <finwitch at y...>
wrote:
> However, what do we except to see? The curse failed. It hit back
to
> Voldemort, saving Harry. Are you certain that the shadowy figures
> beginning to pace around wasn't the echo of that failed spell?
That
> they encourage Harry, and whisper something to Voldemort?
> Sure, enduring something or killing someone has given visible
echo,
> torture a scream (that was heard) - I don't see why the curse that
> failed couldn't have been the one that made the figures pace
around...
>
> Or maybe just that nothing happened?
>
> -- Finwitch
Sorry, I didn't include enough information. The two shadowy figures
are named specifically as Cedric and Frank earlier in the text. I
was typing in a hurry this morning and omited that part. I think
it's just missing. I think that it is possible that given the
description of Bertha joining the others, that Harry failed to
notice the reguitation of the failed curse. There seems to be more
of an authorial gap in this description than there is in the first
two descriptions.
I would look it up for you, but I am not moving. Sorry, blame
intramural volleyball.
--Meg
Read the untold story of life as a first year medical student at:
As The Scalpel Turns - http://www.livejournal.com/users/megd/
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive