What If... Dumbledore had included Fudge in GoF Ch.35?
erinellii
erinellii at yahoo.com
Fri Apr 11 20:11:39 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 55203
And me:
> Is all this "What if"ing meant to cast suspicion on Dumbledore's
> motives? If so, then I think it is wrong-headed. I believe that
> Dumbledore expected Fudge to question Crouch Jr. and hear all the
> things he, Harry, Snape and McGonagall heard. Thus he'd have been
> included. It demonstrates Fudge's extreme limitations (and I agree
> with Taryn also, his link to the DE's in some way) that he chose to
> bring a dementor despite McGonagall's objections and that he chose
to allow the dementor to administer the kiss before hearing the
complete testimony and letting whatever form of WW justice exists to
take its course. The whole thing is fishy and fishy for a reason.
This is meant to show us a side of Fudge and to cover up some
important information.
> JenD
This says it exactly. In my opinion, Dumbledore was not trying
to "hide" anything from Fudge concerning Crouch Jr. He fully
expected him to hear all the testimony, and could not have forseen
the Dementor's Kiss taking that opportunity away.
Probably the reason Fudge was not with them when they originally
questioned them was that he was with Cedric Diggory's parents.
Someone in authority needed to be with them at that time, and Fudge
was the best candidate.
Erin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive