Dobby as a Spy

[Steve]

No: HPFGUIDX 55333

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "bohcoo" <sydenmill at m...> wrote:

> ...big edit...
> 
> I truly believe Malfoy sent Dobby to prevent Harry's return to 
> Hogwarts so he, Malfoy, could make sure Harry didn't interfere 
> with his plans to have Ginny Weasley open the Chamber, discredit 
> Arthur Weasley and perhaps get rid of some Mudbloods in the process.
>  
> Watch out for Dobby.
>  
>  Bohcoo


bboy_mn:

As much as I don't accept your D.I.E. (Dobby Is Evil) theory, I have
to say you made an excellent case for your position. 

While you made a very convincing argument, I personally think Dobby's
affection for Harry is too genuine for Dobby to be evil. I might be
able to go as far as believing that Malfoy sent Dobby, but not so far
as to believe that Dobby was acting in Malfoy's interest instead of
Harry's.

Just a thought.

bboy_mn