Hogwarts's Security

David dfrankiswork at netscape.net
Tue Apr 15 17:26:07 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 55373

Eileen wrote:

> I was and
> continue to be disturbed by the security of Hogwarts.
> Sure, no one can apparate on the grounds, but anyone
> can fly in on broomsticks as proved by the Norbert
> episode in PS/SS. I would wonder if this were
> Hogwarts's Achilles Heel, except that the possibility
> that Sirius Black had entered from the air is not even
> considered in PoA, leading me to think that it's a
> mistake in JKR's conception of Hogwarts.

Doesn't Ron or Hermione suggest in GOF to 'Moody' that Crouch Sr 
could have been kidnapped on a broomstick?

Crouch Jr might have some weird reason to mislead the trio into 
thinking Hogwarts security is laxer than it really is, but I think 
it's more likely that you can get in and out by broomstick.

At the end of PS does Dumbledore make some remark about crossing in 
the air, implying he was coming back from London by air?

David





More information about the HPforGrownups archive