SHIP (FITD)

[Petra Pan]

No: HPFGUIDX 55468

Penny:
> Will reply separately to Petra's points,
> with whom I am more in agreement
> than she seems to think.  <g>

<pout>

I read the whole post to find only this!?!

<over it>

Just so that we're on the same page, I asked 
"Chris foreshadowed"? not because I didn't 
know you were talking about Columbus and his 
spin on ship as portrayed on screen.  I'm 
just not entirely clear on how you 
interpreted CC's interpretation.  In other 
words, exactly what do you think is 
being foreshadowed?

Though really, the above is beside the point 
(and belonging to the movie list).  So what 
is my point?  Read on...

Penny:
> And, I think this recent
> interview on the DVD trumps that "they
> are platonic" quote, because if the
> "they are platonic" quote was intended to
> be as broad as the R/H'ers would have us
> believe, then it's a no-brainer that JKR
> would have said, "certain feelings between
> ...er....two of the three."

Let's flow the above argument, shall we?
Penny, let me know if I misread you.

     *     *     *

IF the "they are platonic" quote was 
intended to be as broad as the R/H'ers 
would have us believe

THEN JKR surely would be of the R/H 
mindset and

THEREFORE JKR would have said, "certain 
feelings between...er....two of the 
three" in reflection of such a mindset

SINCE she did not say so

THEN the "they are platonic" quote cannot 
be intended to be as broad as the R/H'ers 
would have us believe

     *     *     *

Your assertion would be true ONLY if JKR 
have reasons to clear any and all confusion.

My point is that since JKR has no reason to 
clear any and all confusion at this point 
in time, the above argument is not sound.

Sorry, should have done this in the first 
place, eh?

Petra
a
n  :)

__________________________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
The New Yahoo! Search - Faster. Easier. Bingo
http://search.yahoo.com