What about Lupin?

[ameliagoldfeesh]

No: HPFGUIDX 55536

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "a_rude_mechanical" 
<a_rude_mechanical at y...> wrote:
> I had an interesting thought while rereading PoA.  I have always 
> loved Lupin, he's one of my favorite characters.  He's interesting 
> and he always remains so calm and cool.  But this time, I had a 
> totally different emotional reaction to him.   This is my 
question:  
> is it possible that Lupin is not the good person that we believe 
him 
> to be?
<Snip>

> What do y'all think??
> 
> Elisabeth

Well, if you go back in the achives (a task worthy of Hercules with 
Yahoo Search)you'll find message 39362 by Pippin who started 
the "Lupin is Ever-So-Evil" line of thought. Whole threads are 
dedicated to defending or defaming the LYCANTHROPE.

Helpfully Yours,

A Goldfeesh

scene from Scaramouche: Mary Antoinette and Noel de Maynes upon 
finding an illegal pamphlet hidden in the Queen's room)
N: (reading the title of the pamphlet): "Liberty, equality, 
fraternity."
A: "Noel, the people that write such things...what do they really 
want?!"