Hermione's Magical Power (Was: Re: Lily & Petunia Evans (& Who's more magical?))
Laura
metslvr19 at yahoo.com
Fri Apr 18 02:21:43 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 55581
Marci asked:
> > >
So, does this mean Harry (with two magical parents) is more powerful
than Voldemort (with one magical parent)?
"herm - own - ninny" wrote:
> > >
I think JKR has made it clear that a wizard's/witch's magical ability
does not depend on their lineage. Hermione has no magical parents and
she's the best in the year.
> > >
Now me: Sorry, you're going to have to be the victim of my
nitpicking, simply because this is a good opening for something I've
been wanting to bring up.
Just how powerful *is* Hermione? I know she's an excellent witch,
but as far as I can tell, there isn't much canon to support that
she's incredibly magically powerful. She studies all the time and
probably knows about 10 times more spells than Harry and Ron put
together, but does that necessarily mean she's very powerful?
There are a lot of references in canon to her study habits, her
intelligence, and so on...but as far as I can tell there's not much
to support her being an incredibly powerful witch. Not to say that
she's a bad witch, but intelligence does not equal power.
Thoughts?
-Laura
P.S. Feel free to argue, I usually miss obvious points when I bring
things up =)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive