Snape at the end of GoF and Snape's danger

laurence59 laurence59 at yahoo.com
Sun Apr 20 21:28:15 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 55722

I think Snape loved Lily.
I do *not* think they had any kind of a "thing" going or were ever a 
couple. I think he loved her and loves her still; I think he worked 
himself up to confess it to her; I think she let him down easy so 
that he does not hate her; I think she only later became James' girl.



I LOVE your idea. COuld this also what Dumbledore is going to tell 
Harry in OotP?

Another thought of mine... In the trial where Karkarov named names 
and in particular,  he named Snape. Dumbledore then stood up and said 
that Snape turned spy against Voldemort. As these trials are reported 
(Rita Skeeter was in Bagman's), would it not be unreasonable to 
suggest that LV knows about Snape's spying and would therefore not 
welcome him back into the fold. Even if they are not reported, people 
who were in the trial may talk about it...

Just a thought


Laurence







More information about the HPforGrownups archive