Contacting parents, Dumbledore
maria_kirilenko
maria_kirilenko at yahoo.com
Wed Apr 23 18:48:09 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 55982
I wrote:
> But as for the Petrified students - Dumbledore and everyone else
knew
> that they were going to be alright, and that they were actually
safer
> than anyone else. So, uh, extrapolating from the fact that
> Dumbledore, apparently, didn't tell the Weasleys about Pettigrew
and
> Sirius Black, I conclude that the parents were not contacted in
CoS.
> Feel free to disagree, though. <g>
Andrea wrote:
*waves hand* I disagree. :) I think there's a vast difference between
notifying parents of Petrified students and the whole
Scabbers/Pettigrew
debate. The former involves an official action as the Headmaster of
the
school, the latter only a personal action based on his knowledge of
extra-curricular events, so to speak. He has the DUTY as Headmaster
to
notify parents under certain instances, and I think a child being
Petrified -- whether or not there's a cure available -- is definitely
one
of them! (Would Dumbledore just HOPE Colin's parents don't notice
that
their child doesn't write them from *November* on, doesn't come home
for
Christmas, etc? Please.)
Me:
Ummm <sheepish look>. I hadn't thought of that. Ok, point conceded.
Although I don't know about that "Duty as Headmaster" part... I'm not
sure it would be the most important factor in making a decision for
Dumbledore. He does tend to set up experiments in Hogwarts, what with
the Philosopher's Stone and Lockhart and the Time-Turner.
>Dumbledore CAN'T take official action on the Scabbers situation,
>because
>the official position is that Peter Pettigrew is dead and Scabbers
>is a
>rat.
Agreed.
>So any action he'd take is a purely personal one in which he's
>free to use his own judgment to conclude that the Weasleys are not
>in danger.
Ah, but should he take such responsibility upon himself? I don't
think so. It's still ultimately the Weasleys's business to decide if
they're in danger or not.
I do hope we're going to see a scene where Molly is listening to the
explanation of *why*, exactly, Sirius Black was at Hogwarts at the
end of GoF, and *why* Ron told her that it was okay, and *how*, they
all know that Pettigrew is alive. I'd love to see her reaction. It
would be rather funny, no? After all, there must a recap of the
previous books anyway, so why not have it in this form?
>I don't think there's really any comparison between the two
>decisions.
I suppose you're right. But I still think that Dumbledore should've
told the Weasleys about Scabbers.
Maria,
who double-checks the facts in books if she thinks that she's
suffering from movie contamination, but who had completely forgotten
that it was Percy who'd sent the owl to his parents in CoS.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive