Freindship outside trio -Draco Malfoy - Snape/Black

darrin_burnett bard7696 at aol.com
Fri Apr 25 14:57:59 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 56135

> First the old 'this has probably already been discussed' disclaimer.. Does 
> this mean that Ginny would owe Harry a life debt for saving her life in CoS? 
> And Ron and Harry would owe Hermione a life debt for saving their lives in 
> PS/SS, when she saved them from the Devils Snare?
> 
> ~Faith~
> 
> 

Good question. Two answers why I say no.

1) Dumbledore hasn't told us they do. He told us about Wormtail's debt to 
Harry. 

2) Perhaps the life debt is a little like Veritaserum in that it compels a wizard to 
do something he or she wouldn't ordinarily do. Given 1,000 chances to save 
Hermione's life, Ron and Harry would do so 1,000 times, so a magical debt 
compelling them might not be necessary.

Darrin
-- I'm at work. Can't think of any band names. Gotta run.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive