Rita the DE at Hogwarts?
darrin_burnett
bard7696 at aol.com
Fri Apr 25 22:27:36 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 56180
Lynn:
>
> Voldemort says that his loyal DE is at Hogwarts.
> Most take that to mean Crouch, Jr. But, after
> Harry returns to Hogwarts Crouch, Jr. asks Harry
> if the Dark Lord has really returned. That seems
> to indicate that he doesn't have the Dark Mark
> otherwise he would have known Voldemort was back
> just as Snape does.
Me:
Snape and Karakoff's Dark Marks were acting up all year, steadily growing
darker all year, well before V-Mort successfully performed the ritual that gave
him human form.
I think Crouch was asking if Voldemort managed to perform the ritual, rather
than "is he back?"
> Voldemort also tells Wormtail that there will be
> one more death and then the Dementor applies the
> Kiss so now Crouch, Jr. is worse than dead. That
> has always seemed to me to be too convenient to
> have been done just at the spur of the moment.
> It just seems too planned.
I always figured the death was Harry's.
> So, I was thinking about who else has been at
> Hogwarts the whole year and Rita Skeeter has.
> Dumbledore makes a point of saying that Voldemort
> is good at causing enmity and what better way
> than through the media? Rita went out of her way
> to write divisive articles all year, especially
> about Harry and his friends, the very ones who
> could arguably rally the community against
> Voldemort.
>
> Thoughts?
I've disagreed with your reasoning, but I don't disagree with your conclusion.
Rita would make an EXCELLENT DE.
And just because Voldemort didn't tell his DEs at the graveyard about her , or
include her in the Mouseketeer roll call doesn't mean she isn't one of his
followers. You think V-Mort tells knuckle-draggers like Mr. Crabbe and Mr.
Goyle every little detail? Hell, no, he doesn't.
Of course, she's in a bottle somewhere now. Wonder if V-Mort stages an
assault on Casa Granger to get her back?
Darrin
-- Assault on Casa Granger. Whoever uses that as a fanfic title owes me a
quarter every time it's read.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive