Teacher Ratings (Was: Why I hate Hagrid (was: I Hate Snape...))

[mongo62aa]

No: HPFGUIDX 56380

OK, as long as we are discussing Hogwarts teachers, let's look at all 
of them.  I will start with 8 points, and subtract points for 
problems with the teacher.  This is, of course, subjective, but I am 
open to other ideas.  In alphabetical order:

Binns - Magical History - 3 points 

(lack of useful curriculum, minus 3 points, inability to hold 
student's attention, minus 2 points)

Hagrid, Care of Magical Creatures - 4 points 

(lack of proper classroom safety precautions, minus 2 points, lack of 
proper curriculum, minus 2 points)

Flitwick - Charms - 8 points 

(no problems)

McGonnagall - Transfiguration - 7 points 

(somewhat unfair with house points (against Gryffindor), minus 1 
point)

Snape - Potions - 0 points 

(grossly unfair with house points, minus 3 points, cruel to targeted 
students, minus 4 points, undercuts other teachers, minus 1 point) 

Sprout - Herbology - 8 points 

(no problems)

Trelawney - Divination - 3 points 

(shows favoritism with students, minus 1 point, lack of ability in 
own field, minus 3 points, poor classroom conditions, minus 1 point)

I really don't have enough information to make a judgement on the 
following:

Hooch - Flying & Quidditch
Sinistra - Astronomy
Vector - Arithmancy
? - Muggle Studies
? - Ancient Runes
? - Defence Against Dark Arts

Bill