A dumbledore question

juniormandrake80 juniormandrake80 at yahoo.co.uk
Wed Apr 30 23:10:54 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 56664

Hello - sorry I haven'te been online for a while, and I'm a bit 
behind but I wondered if I could pose a question:

Has anyone thought about the possibility of Dumbledore being on 
Voldemorts side? I mean, In GOF, when Harry is looking at the 
Pensieve, Dumbledore recalls SNape saying that "It's coming back.. 
Karakoff's tpp... stronger and clearer than ever..." meaning the dark 
mark (p.517) and Dumbledore merely says " A connection I could have 
made without assistance, but never mind". COuld this mean that 
Dumbledore is a double-agent, having the dark mark himself and so 
being able to see it himself? Could Voldemort NOT be afraid of him, 
or be afraid of him because he is in CONTROL of Voldemort? Or is 
Voldemort not afraid because they are on the same side? I just wonder 
what people think of this idea. The ambiguous state of the characters 
goodness and evilness is quite blurred, so could it be possible? I 
look forward to some reactions, if it hasn't already been said!

Lisa XX






More information about the HPforGrownups archive