Why did Harry get such a liking of Sirius to start with ?

Doriane delwynmarch at yahoo.com
Fri Aug 1 09:41:23 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 74609

"flying_meese" wrote:
 
> I don't know if love has anything to do with it yet. I see it this 
> way, in PoA Harry is 13, he has spent 13 years with a family who 
> wants absolutely nothing to do with him, he's spent 3 years at 
> Hogwarts trying not to get killed, now his fathers best friend 
> wants him to come live with him. He jumps at the chance because for 
> probably the first time in his life he feels really wanted by 
> someone. I think anyone would jump at that chance if they had been 
> through the same things.

But what about the Weasleys ? I think they've made it pretty clear 
that they would take him for good if only DD allowed it. And still he 
doesn't feel anywhere as strongly towards them.

I know Sirius has a bonus, since he's his dad's best friend, but 
we've never seen Harry so intent on getting to know more about his 
parents anyway. When he discovers that Remus was also a friend of his 
dad's, he doesn't care.

So I'm still feeling uneasy about the whole matter of "Sirius was 
soooo important for Harry". I love Sirius, but I don't buy that 
artificial relationship between him and Harry JKR tries to force us 
to buy throughout GoF and OoP. I remember when I was younger, I need 
*acts* of love, not just words or family ties. I would have been much 
more attracted to the Weasleys than to Sirius.

Del





More information about the HPforGrownups archive