Snape's (un)fair grading

Deb readzalot at shaw.ca
Fri Aug 1 16:28:05 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 74702

Snape intentionally made Harry get a zero in Potions, when Harry
obviously made it correctly.

I think it was a good lesson for Harry to learn - even if you do it
right, do not leave your work unattended in the face of those who you
do not trust.

I bet Harry will never just drop off his potion and turn away again.

I bet Harry will never make a potion outside of class and leave it
unattended.

But, we don't know (yet) whether Snape enjoyed doing it because he is
mean, or whether he did it because of "tough love" or whether the
truth is a bit of both.

Deb S, aka readzalot, Canada






More information about the HPforGrownups archive