Fwd: Re: [HPforGrownups] Neville's Wand / Neville's Plant (Was: OWLs & future Aurors)

[silmariel]

No: HPFGUIDX 74735

[Yahoomort strikes again]

flying_meese:
<<There could also be the possibility that not just any feather from a
Phoenix will work in a wand and that Fawkes has only produced 2 of
these special feathers. >>

You are right. Not any feather, a tail feather, as Ollivander describes in
 PS, I think. If there is another explicit requirement for the feather that
 would exclude the golden tail feather of Fawkes and she has not given it by
 now I would feel cheated by Rowling, you know.

Because the only golden feathers that Fawkes has are in the tail, I think is
described in GoF. Sorry if I can't quote canon but I don't know the books by
heart and my boyfriend has borrowed all of them from me (he's quitting
smoking).

Del
<<Could it be that Neville, when reading the book,
came across that plant and discovered that it has powerful magical
properties that could... cure his parents !?>>

Well, it is again my boyfriend. He 'predicted' before OoP that:
Neville's birthday was near Harry's (he said 24h of difference)
Neville's book was going to be important and it would have to do with his
family, curing his fathers or something like that.

I didn't give him credit, because it was a part of his 'Neville and Harry are
Twin brothers'. It included things like the real Neville Longbottom born dead
or killed by Voldie first. He also has theories as DD being a vampire, so
it's no wonder I don't defend his ideas in this forum, but when I read the
phrophecy and the mimbulus mimbletonia thing, I started looking at him other
way, that's for sure.

I'm with you on this. The book and the plant, together, are going to be
useful.

silmariel