Hermione's Rude Comment

[Trish]

No: HPFGUIDX 74744

> --- watsola79 <watsola79 at y...> wrote:
> > I think she DOES change her point of view regarding the value
> > of 
> > Divination...in the end of OOP, she answers Ron's comment with
> > (sorry 
> > for paraphrasing) "How can you say that?  After we've just
> > found out 
> > that Prophecies are real?"  It was in the battle that the
> > prophecy 
> > became a *fact* for her, even though she did not reach that 
> > conclusion from something she read in a book.  However, her
> > newfound 
> > respect for that branch of magic undoubtedly did nothing to
> > alter her 
> > feelings about Firenze or Trelawney.  


Wait...when did she make the comment about Firenze? Wasn't it before 
the end of the book when she finds  out prophecies are for real? How 
do we know then, that her feelings about Firenze and Trelawney have 
not changed? Maybe they have?
Trish