Theory of the Love, Death, Voldemort (shortened)

[scooting2win]

No: HPFGUIDX 74983

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "scooting2win" 
<scooting2win at y...> wrote:
> (snip) starting with Professor Binns (PB), lets 
> consider a few facts first in OoP, (snip) Also it was Hermoine 
that asked PB about the Chamber in > CoS. PB has been going on and 
on about "facts", Goblin rebellions, giant wars, how things came to 
pass, etc.... (snip) Hogwarts is a school of witches and wizards, 
(bear with me, I have a good point).  Now other then Hermoine's 
class of Arithmancy, there are no regular classes, no math class, no 
english, no literture, that sort of regular class. 
They have "magic" (snip) you have the idea anyway. so why teach 
history of magic? I know its a good idea to teach it to make 
sure that everyone has a good idea of magic, where it came from, 
etc...etc... and if i am correct in this assumption, PB, being a 
ghost, teaching, history of magic, then we have overlooked something 
here. Dumbledore says LV MARKED Harry as an equal, Harry's mother 
marked him with protection, his Aunt furthers this protection by 
allowing Harry to stay there. (snip) that was a spell DD used to 
protect Harry, knowing that as long as he's there for just a month 
every year, (snip) Voldemort took blood from Harry to be "reborn". 
Giving LV the same protection, even though this one I don't think 
works because LV doesn't live in at the Dursley's for a month every 
year, nor do I think he can call it home. (snip) So it would not 
protect him in this manner, nor do I think that LV knows about this 
protection anyway. (snip) Sirius was (sob) harry's godfather. Harry 
loved Sirius so much that when he thought of death he thought well I 
will be with Sirius. Sirius loved Harry so much he died for him 
(basicly). LV fled Harry's body when harry thought this (snip) 
Everyone says that love is more powerful then death? (snip) LV says 
there is nothing worse then death?!. DD tells Harry that LV picked 
the "half-blood" not the "pure-blood". (snip) James was pure-blood? 
Lupin would be a pure-blood given the fact that he longed to go to 
Hogwarts (snip) The four boys (james, sirius, Lupin, and Peter) and 
Lily form a bond at school that is rather brotherly (snip) Peter 
betrayed them all, he broke that bond 
> between them. harry and ron have been friends since the train. 
Neville is included of course because well, he is like a brother to 
Harry when it comes right down to it. (snip) Hermoine and the boys 
have built an amazing > friendship (snip) The Weasleys basicly 
adopted Harry and Hermoine as one of their own. So what I am leading 
up to, this. What if History of Magic is not just teaching them 
about what has happened but teaching them the bonds that matter. 
What do I mean, simple Goblins work together they are united, giants 
don't work together, as Hagrid put it, they are not use to living in 
 groups. Centaurs take no side be it muggle or wizard. House-elves 
are "part" of a family even though they are bound to that family by 
slavery, some of them do love the families that they serve, winky 
for example. Dumbledore stated that they are strong as they are 
united, weak as they are divided. Meaning that they must unite like 
a family, protect one another as if they were your brother/sister. 
(snip) Throughout 5 books, two more to come (and I hope quickly) 
they have fought Voldemort together, Harry's mother and father died 
saving Harry, Dumbledore loves Harry like a son, Sirius was Harry's  
Godfather, Lupin Loved(S) James, Sirius, And harry like they are 
brothers, Harry's Aunt by taking him in is protecting him. Voldemort 
took blood from Harray and everyone thinks Voldemort is scared of 
Death, that love will kill him. it's that bond of family that will 
kill him. Voldemort never had a family, his mother died after having 
him, he murdered his father, He does not consider his Death Eaters 
Family. Upon his rebirth, Voldemort tells Harry his "true" family 
returns. He considers them servants. Harry and Voldemort are 
connected by more than that scar, Voldemort marked Harry as an 
equal, he is reborn using Harry's blood. Their wands share feathers 
from the same Phoenix. Anyone in the book that likes Harry considers 
him family, Voldemort's Death Eaters do not consider Voldemort 
family, they consider him "Master". Like they are House-elves 
waiting for direction from him. (snip) The sorting hat said 
that the founders lived together in Harmony, like a family. The 
sorting Hat has a problem dividing them up into different "houses". 
it does not want them to think of only their other students 
(snip) but to think of others as family as well.(snip) Now that 
Voldemort has used the blood from Harry, he is a "blood-brother" to 
Harry and will not be able to survive with any part of a caring 
family person running through his veins. And one final thought since 
I know that this has been long, but it's just a thought, if 
Dumbledore is correct and Peter is indebted to Harry for saving his 
life against Sirius, since Voldemort used Peter's hand to 
be "reborn" would he not be indebted to Harry as well. I am sure 
that this is old magic, Dumbledore said that it was, and Peter tried 
to warn Voldemort before he did this, but Voldemort does not listen 
to servants. His downfall will be the family that is united at 
Harry's side and not to his. Oh and since you read this far, someone 
posted that the last line of Book 7 was someone asking Harry "Harry 
what happened to your scar?". Now if indeed this is fact 
not "fiction" then if Harry defeats Voldemort by using the "family 
bond" then the mark that Voldemort put on Harry would disappear 
without the connection to Voldemort through Harry's survival. Any 
ideas, anyone?