the Prophecy Harry and James as Voldemort's targets
kateydidnt2002
kateydidnt2002 at yahoo.com
Mon Aug 4 10:53:49 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 75203
Ok, in OotP we find out that Voldemort wanted to kill Harry because
of Trelawney's first prophecy.
So why did Voldemort want to kill James? In SS p294 Voldemort says "I
killed your father first, and he put up a courageous fight...but your
mother needn't have died..." and in book three Harry hears Voldemort
saying "Stand aside, stupid girl!" (or something to that effect-not
looking at my book at the moment)
I have always thought that this meant that Voldemort went there that
night specifically intending on killing both James and Harry, and
Lily didn't really matter. Yet the prophecy only indicates Harry as
the threat, so, logically, Harry should be the only target. I assume
that the part that was overheard and communicated to Voldemort
was: "The one with the power to vanquish the- Dark Lord approaches
born to those who have thrice defied him, born as the seventh month
dies" (This is because Voldemort had to have that much information in
order to narrow the choice of who it was referring to down to Harry
and Neville and I wonder if he heard more, confirming that it was
male or if there were females who also fit the parameters if he heard
none of the masculine pronouns) This indicates only one individual to
be his opponent-the one who is the son of two people who have defied
Voldemort three times and born at the end of July. It says nothing
about the individuals father being a particular threat. So why was
James a target?
If Voldemort wished to kill James simply because he was a strong
Dumbledore supporter or strong opponent to Voldemort wouldn't he have
wanted to kill Lily too because she was just as opposed to Voldemort
OotP (or rather the prophecy) indicates that BOTH Lily and James
defied Voldemort three times indicating, again to me, that Lily was
as dangerous an opponent as her husband. So why would Voldemort be so
intent on killing James and not Lily when both seemed to be working
hard against him and Harry was the only one mentioned in the prophecy?
Random theory on killing James and not Lily-perhaps at the request of
Wormtail?
If this specific question has been addressed, I apologize and ask
that you please direct me to the appropriate posts.
Thanks!
Kateydidnt
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive