Why Couldn't LV get the prophecy for himself?
revaunchanistx
coyandbecky at yahoo.com
Tue Aug 5 02:28:59 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 75410
In the world of evil lords Voldy had an ingenious plan. I think the
one person you are all not mentioning is Lucius Malfoy. Voldemort
puts Lucius in charge of the operation. He did not put either one
of the Lestranges or any of the other 12 escaped dementors in charge.
This leads me to believe that the plan was largely created and
executed by Lucius Malfoy. Earlier in the book we see Lucius
talking to Fudge. I got the feeling that Lucius could spread around
alot of money to many of the MoM employees. Even getting Fudge to
keep the order guard away from the Door to the department of
mysteries.
For Voldemort to physically expose himself to do such a menial task
would be stupid. Haven't you all seen the Godfather. How many times
did Don Corleone kill someone, or do anything by himself. The risks
are too great. Especially when you have someone like Lucius to pull
the strings and execute your plan. The only flaw in the plan was
Harry refusing to give up the orb. I think Harry's reluctance to give
the orb to Lucius was not expected. All of the DE's and Voldemort
had assumed that Harry had already been told about the prophecy. In
assuming that the Harry was aware of the prophecy the DE's and
Voldemort would have deduced that Harry would give up the prophecy
and protect his friends instead of protecting the prophecy.
If Harry had only retreived the prophecy knowing it's contents
curiousity would have not been on his side. He protected the prophecy
only because he thought that the information was valuable to the
DE's. He did not protect the orb because of the nature of the
prophecy. If Dumbledore had told Harry the prophecy, he would have
been more apt to throw the prophecy or use it as a barganing tool for
the lives of his friends rather than have his friends risk their
lives to protect it.
The idea that an evil person should just do this, or it would have
been much better to do this, is repetive and has all been said
before. Isn't that the whole premise behind "Austin Powers." We are
all evil genuises at heart and can think up some great plans. However
I plan on holding off discussing mine until one actually works. Then
I can say another evil genius's plan is dumb.
PS: Read the books again and focus on Lucius; he truly is a very
skilled and evil person. He is not refered to as the most loyal DE,
but he is obviously the most gifted and most used by Voldemort. Maybe
not most trusted. But then again in the evil genius handbook your
most loyal follower may not be your best man.
"revaunchanistx"
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive