[HPforGrownups] Is Snape to be Trusted

[Irene Mikhlin]

No: HPFGUIDX 75458



Random wrote:

>>Snape should understand that Occlumency is weakening his mind instead 
>>of doing the opposite, and still throws him out after Harry's pensieve 
>>experience.
> 
> 
> perhaps he throws him out BECAUSE of it - he doesn't want to weaken his 
> mind any further.

Oh, that's a beautiful theory.
Dumbledore forces Snape to give Harry these lessons. Snape realizes that 
they do not help at all - Harry's connection to Voldie is something 
other than Legilimency. But arguing with Dumbledore is fruitless.
So he creates this situation to achieve what he wanted - the end of the 
lessons. The only trouble is I don't believe he wanted Harry to see his 
memories, no way.

Irene