Why Lupin can't be evil!

[tomatogrower88]

No: HPFGUIDX 75526

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Melanie Black 
<princessmelabela at y...> wrote:
> I have toyed with writing this for weeks now, ever since the first 
evil Lupin scenario and while I realize most people are not advocating 
this theory I just have to put in my say as to why it would devistate 
the entire story  (and in my opinion do much more than that if Lupin 
turns out to be evil) 
> ~Mela

I have to agree with you on this. For him to be evil would, in my 
opinion, be over the top. The major betrayer for James' group was 
Peter. If Lupin turns out to be evil it makes the whole bertayal issue 
too much of a bad thing. I do not see evil Lupin adding anything to 
the plot. Much of my opinion is hopeful. I went and reread POA and OOP 
to find any thing to disprove ESE Lupin. I could not find any new 
points just what I have stated above. I like Lupin I would feel bad if 
he turned out ESE.

Myrth